The UBC Department of Family Practice is pleased to offer two-year, part-time, Clinician Scholar positions for family physicians in family practice scholarship starting July 1 each year. Quick Find Director’s Message Hello and Welcome to UBC’s Family Medicine CaRMS Pages! Program Director 2 Department of Family Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada. Dr. Diana Stancu In 2013, Canadian medical graduates applied to an average of 14 programs.2 That year, the first iteration match rate for this group was 95% (2590 of 2735), and 86% (2355 of 2735) were matched to their first-choice discipline. This training opportunity represents one of the pathways for obtaining the Provincial Hospital Medicine Clinical Privileges. For the 3-schools group, consistency decreased from fair in 2007 (ICC = 0.44) to very weak in 2013 (ICC = 0.17) (Table 3). On a utilisé le principe de justice distributive pour concevoir le projet, le fait de se conformer à ce principe étant la preuve que le classement des étudiants est équitable dans tous les programmes. The goal of this program is to train physicians who are intent on practicing in rural communities to be competent in performing C-sections. Prince George, Kelowna/Kamloops, Victoria or Nanaimo), encompasses a broad selection of Women’s Health disciplines, incorporates focused time in two individually chosen areas of skill development, offers the opportunity to spend two weeks in a Women’s Health focused clinical practice, provides training oriented around specified learning objectives. Dr. Jason Crookham Our Family Medicine Residency Program is dedicated to the development of competent family physicians providing comprehensive, continuous care. The first year of residency training is known as "Postgraduate Year 1" (PGY1). The design is intended to provide adequate volume of clinical exposure to achieve learning objectives while still providing adequate exposure to rural broad spectrum FPA practice to prepare our residents for the unique challenges they will face working in rural surgical and critical care environments  with limited resources. At the core of our program is a family practice that serves as your home base, with a family physician as the primary preceptor for the full two years. This again indicates a low likelihood of students applying to programs or sites in each of these groups being ranked similarly by more than 1 site. These combined programs vary from 5–6 years in length. As with other Category 2 Programs, specific training locations are dependent on the resident's own goals and objectives. Dmyra088@uottawa.ca. Our alumni boast a high quality medical education, and are confident to practice in family medicine anywhere in Saskatchewan, nationally, and in the world. Email: rrsaona@gmail.com, Dr. Sally Barrio Abortion education in Canadian family medicine residency programs BMC Med Educ . Overall facilitation of the program is the responsibility of the CSP Director, Dr. Wendy Norman, with the oversight and guidance of the CSP Steering Committee. A brief outline of year structure is as follows: Successful completion of this enhanced skills program requires passing: Specific FPA CBD curriculum is in process of being developed, Dr. John McAlpine This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Program Assistant - Enhanced Skills The discipline of family medicine from a research perspective is at a critical juncture and in order to ensure the future of family medicine research PhD trained family physicians are fundamental. The Enhanced Skills HIV-AIDS program has been re-structure to adapt to the changes in the management of this chronic condition. This exposure depends on learning objectives if you have preference to shadow certain clinics, Will be evaluated by the Primary Care Maternity rotation supervisor, Surrey Memorial NICU (3 weeks) - this training would have emphasis  on neonatal resuscitation and stabilization, and care of the “older” premature infant, Surrey Memorial Pediatric Consult service (3 weeks) – assessment and stabilization of term infants, and management of common pediatric consultations/inpatient care, BC Children’s Hospital Emergency Room (2 weeks) – this will allow exposure to General Pediatrics but also a significant exposure to pediatric acute mental health disorders, Regional Hospital Experence (4 weeks) – experience in “full service” General Pediatric hospital practice, which includes neonatal care (resuscitation and stabilization) ideally in the regional hospital serving the trainee’s planned practice area (eg. The focus of the study was therefore on the outcome (consistency of student rank position) and not the process of selection itself. Email: lindsay.gowland@familymed.ubc.ca. Family Medicine residency training programs began in Canada in 1966 and in Saskatchewan in 1971. Email: tamar.haytayan@familymed.ubc.ca, Jill Delane This is a high volume, high acuity department with both adult and pediatric emergency departments. Do you have an idea for how to improve practice, health care delivery or any aspect of community-based primary health care? Abortion education in Canadian family medicine residency programs Daniel T. Myran*, Jillian Bardsley, Tania El Hindi and Kristine Whitehead Abstract Background: Abortion has been decriminalized in Canada since 1988 and is considered an essential medical service. Email: Anoo.Tamber@ubc.ca, Kathryn Inman 24 Positions are 8-8-8 (Traditional Family Medicine) Due to COVID-19 the residency program will be conducting virtual interviews only for the 2021 Match year Initial analysis reviewed how students who applied to more than 1 of any of the 109 FM residency sites across Canada in 2013 were ranked by each site or program. Program Director Surrey: Surrey Memorial Hospital is the busiest emergency department in the province. Our residency programs at Queen's University are nationally respected for its collegial atmosphere, high faculty-to-resident ratio, research opportunities, and strong focus on teaching in all of the major subspecialties as well as General Internal Medicine. Students apply to their program of interest; however, programs do not rank all the applicants, nor do they rank the same applicant pool. Canadian applicants are doctors who are Canadian citizens or who have permanent resident status in Canada. The overall program objectives are defined in terms of the CanMEDS competencies; the resident will be expected to define a set of shorter term learning objectives tailored to individual interests and goals to achieve within the 6-month training program. The University of Manitoba is one of the best international medical residency programs you can choose from. Address province specifics Individual learning objectives could also be accommodated. The focus of the study was therefore on the outcome (consistency of student rank position) and not the process of selection itself. Email: mcmeelkv@gmail.com. Only higher-level criteria (rural site, larger urban-based site, location) were used to build subsets for analysis. Enhanced Skills offers a primary care Sports and Exercise Medicine year of training. ▸ As the intent of all Canadian FM residency programs is to train residents to practise anywhere in Canada, and therefore desired selection attributes should be similar, such a low level of consistency in ranking strongly suggests a failure to meet the distributive justice rule of equity, where the outcome of a selection process is dependent upon the attributes that each applicant brings to the process. Note: This menu is not an exhaustive list. Education Program Coordinator - BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS Email: csp.assistant@familymed.ubc.ca. Email: tina.webber@ubc.ca. Understand the theoretical foundations of Family Medicine. This program is a continuation of the CCFP Residency Program and is designed to meet the needs of the physician who wishes to acquire extra skills in Emergency Medicine. It will be largely based on the existing Addictions Fellowship offered by the BC Centre on Substance Use. Happy Holidays from the CaRMS family to yours. The clinical placement can be extended beyond the R3 program at the resident's discretion and pending site approval. The lore of admissions policies: contrasting formal and informal understandings of the residency selection process. They are provincial leaders in ultrasound training. The CSP Mentorship Agreement guides the level and type of support the Clinician Scholar will receive. PSM Pediatric Subspecialty Match. The initial training will be a three (3) month period with rotations through areas managing acute pediatric and neonatal presentations. Greer Family Medicine Residency is a new three-year, community-based program located at Prisma Health Greer Memorial Hospital in Greer, South Carolina. Dr Wycliffe-Jones prepared the first draft of the article and all authors critically revised the subsequent drafts. Email: john_mcalpine@telus.net, Tamar Haytayan Email: ksinman@mail.ubc.ca. Training periods of up to 3 months are available in Category 2 Palliative Medicine. (These data would apply more to a study focused on the student experience of a selection process and the degree of application of rules around procedural justice.). These covariance parameters were then used to calculate the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) for all programs. Although these results confirm a low level of consistency of ranking of the same students, one could argue that, as more students choose FM as their discipline of choice,3,20 many FM programs in Canada have moved from recruitment mode to selection mode. The program, though very clinically based, has a strong academic component. 2. The category two Addiction Medicine program seeks to educate and train practicing clinicians to identify and treat substance use disorders with three months of focused rotations. For the incoming 2019-2020 year, 2 of the CCFP-EM positions are based in Nanaimo, while the remainder are based at St. Paul's Hospital in Vancouver. The nature of the selection process imposed limitations on data analysis. The SPH-IMG Residency Site is unique in Canada, and globally as well, in that it is restricted to residency training in Family Medicine for doctors who have trained in countries other than Canada or the U.S. Program Lead - Nanaimo The program is based primarily in Vancouver or Victoria, but there will be opportunity to gain palliative care experience in other B.C. An International Medical Graduate (IMG) is a Canadian citizen or permanent resident who graduates from a medical school outside of Canada. The Path to Residency In Canada, candidates for medical residency are matched to universities […] University of British Columbia offers one position for 6 (six) months of R3 Enhanced Skills in Hospital Medicine training and mentorship in integrated hospitalized complex patient, family and system-centered healthcare. The Department of Family and Community Medicine's (DFCM) Residency Program prepares future family physicians for comprehensive primary care in an evolving health care system. If you are a FP physician who is going into rural practice that incudes maternity care and obstetrics without an Obstetrician, then it is advisable to request to spend more time as an Ob Group resident working with the Obstetricians, Will have exposure to various Women’s health clinics including prenatal,  menopause, obstetrics medicine, gynecology clinics and more depending on availability. Explore the wide variety of specialized training programs below that our Enhanced Skills Program for third-year residents and physicians. Dr. Conrad Rusnak Unfilled positions after the 2021 FM/ES match. Annual visits are on average over 165K. NOTE: We only request your email address so that the person you are recommending the page to knows that you wanted them to see it, and that it is not junk mail. It is possible to train in obstetrics at other locations but it is generally up to the resident to seek out the opportunity and design their own learning plan. The site is part of the overall UBC Family Medicine Program and follows common policy, curriculum and overall governance. Five subsets of sites were created based on this analysis (Table 1). Subset analyses reveal similar, mostly low, levels of consistency even when examining how students who apply to sites with similar profiles or stated training focus (eg, rural FM) are ranked. Saskatchewan has trained more than 1,000 family doctors for Saskatchewan and Canada. ▸ This study found that the likelihood of the same medical student applying to more than 1 FM residency program being ranked similarly by each program was low. The resulting Canadian Residency Matching Service (CaRMS) “match” maximizes, using a computerized algorithm, the ROLs of programs’ candidate preferences and the ROLs of students’ program preferences to allocate where and in which discipline individuals will commence residency training.1, This resource-intensive process for programs involves considerable expense and stress for students who might travel across Canada for selection interviews. We will help you to develop your research ideas into scholarship. * There is a separate admission process for IMGs to Family Medicine Residency, which involves CaRMS, assignment to a cohort group, a pre-residency training program and an assessment verification period. In 2017, obstetrics-gynecology was an especially competitive specialty, with 113 Canadian medical graduates vying for 77 residency spots. Phone: 250-370-8980 Design Descriptive cross-sectional study. PCM Rotation: AKA “Single Room Maternity Care” rotation. The western province rural FM group demonstrated improved consistency in ranking over recent years to a moderate consistency in 2013 (ICC = 0.55). Victoria, BC V8R 1J8. Our residents are expected to attend weekly scheduled Internal Medicine rounds, and Monthly Hospitalist Grand rounds. family practice, assessment and treatment program. Email: pbennett@providencehealth.bc.ca, Dr. Kevin McMeel There are up to four positions available each academic year (July 1-June 30). In reviewing these results, based on the low levels of consistency, the distributive justice rule of equity in the ranking of students is not being met. This is a requirement to apply to the Clinician Scholar Program. It also provides opportunities for enhanced learning local global health, including refugees and new immigrants. Email: maged.bakhet@amaraclinics.ca. Triple C Competency-based Curriculum Report – Part 2 aims to assist in the full implementation of Triple C by all stakeholders. Typically, an ICC of 0.29 or less indicates weak consistency; between 0.3 and 0.49 indicates fair consistency; between 0.5 and 0.69 indicates moderate consistency; and 0.7 or greater indicates strong consistency.19. Program Assistant - Enhanced Skills Former residents’ online reviews of family medicine residency programs can be quite interesting and instructive to read, but you should view them with some caution. Our goal is to develop leaders, teachers and researchers in elder care in the community. Use the AAFP Family Medicine Residency Directory to find residency programs by location, community setting, international medicine opportunities, and more. Hierarchical linear modeling accounts for the issue of nesting (nonindependence of ranks within students), addresses the concern of missing data, and accommodates for the different number of rankings within students.17,18 The results of this analysis—the within-student and between-student covariance parameter estimates—were then used to calculate a consistency coefficient via an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Discipline choices of Canadian applicants. Conclusion In most cases, there is a low level of consistency of ranking of students applying for FM training in Canada. Canada. The Category 1 Addictions program is new to UBC for the 2021-22 year. This analysis was repeated for all sites in Canada between 2007 and 2013. Consent was obtained from the senior faculty individual (ie, Associate and Assistant Deans of Postgraduate Medical Education) at all 17 Canadian medical schools to access the anonymized rank-order data of students applying to all FM residency programs in the first iteration of CaRMS from 2007 to 2013. Consistency of ranking of students across all FM residency training sites in each CaRMS cycle from 2007 to 2013, by year, Subset analysis of CaRMS data for consistency of ranking of students applying to more than 1 FM training site in each CaRMS cycle from 2007 to 2013, by site group. The hypothesis was that the degree of consistency would be high and the outcome of this part of the selection process (the ranking of students) should therefore be perceived as fair, based on evidence of compliance with the distributive justice rule of equity. Should students applying to FM residency training in Canada expect to be ranked similarly by different sites, particularly when the sites might be similar; when the sites publish similar or exactly the same selection criteria; where standards for training are the same for all FM training sites21; where the expectation and intent is to train family physicians so that they are prepared to enter early professional practice anywhere in Canada; and where training is funded from the public purse? Welcome to the McGill Family Medicine Postgraduate Residency Program The Department of Family Medicine offers a fully accredited two-year postgraduate training program based in a primary care training centre in one of McGill's teaching units. In 2013, the 17 residency programs had 109 sites available among them. The distributive justice rule of equity was used to frame the project; compliance with this rule would provide evidence of a fair process in how students are ranked across programs. FM/ES Family Medicine / Enhanced Skills Match. Program Director Completion of an APLS course is also recommended. Enhanced Skills trainees enter with the goal of providing specialized care to a particular community by developing focused competencies within Addiction Medicine. They must satisfy one of the following criteria: On completion of the program, the physician will be able to provide primary and consultant palliative care services, including the education of medical students and physicians, and receive the right to use the CCFP-PC (Palliative Care) Certificate of Added Competence (CAC) designation. The UBC FPA year is a diverse and challenging blend of high volume/high acuity tertiary centre rotations and rural FPA educational experiences. Participants All 17 Canadian medical schools allowed access to their anonymized program rank-order lists of students applying to FM residency programs submitted to the first iteration of the Canadian Resident Matching Service match from 2007 to 2013. If within-student variability is larger than the between-student variability, the ICC will be low. There are also a variety of elective options available depending on the specific interests of the resident. Of note, although this represents a high match rate for discipline of choice, only 63% (1710 of 2735) of graduates matched to their first-choice program location.3. Hospitalist Royal Columbian Hospital Program Coordinator - RC Anesthesia Program We did not review CaRMS webpages for stated selection criteria for sites open to applicants between 2007 and 2012; it is possible that the selection criteria in some of the sites included in the subsets changed over this time; however, this was considered unlikely. Canadian Medical Residency Canadians who have trained in medical schools outside Canada and the US can compete for and obtain medical residency positions in Canada. We … Six-month advanced obstetrics surgical skills training is available at Surrey Memorial Hospital. Vancouver: St Paul's: St. Paul's is a busy, fascinating and gritty tertiary-care hospital in the heart of downtown Vancouver with an annual census of 88K. The CFPC accredits postgraduate family medicine training in Canada’s medical schools. Will join a number of ambulatory clinics including obstetrics and some gynecology if available. Training in low-risk obstetrics with Enhanced Skills usually takes place at BC Women's Hospital + Health Centre. For more information about the program, please visit our Global Health Enhanced Skills webpage. Typical methods of assessing reliability (κ, Cronbach α, or Krippendorff α) require more complete data (meaning a large number of schools ranking the same candidates) to calculate a reliability coefficient and do not take into consideration the nesting issue with the data. Adult anesthesia: A total of 6 blocks at Vancouver General Hospital, St. Paul’s Hospital, Lions Gate Hospital, and/or Royal Columbian Hospital. For more information on Addiction Medicine Medicine Training including the Category 1 program, please refer to the BC Centre on Substance Use, http://www.bccsu.ca/. If you are interested in applying to this program BC Women ’ s office does... Identified Family practice faculty research mentor testing whether or not you are in., at Alberta Health Services in Calgary rank position ) and not the of. Researchers in elder care in the Department of Family Physicians of Canada Diagnostic Sciences the... Are very limited, so use our resources for the best chance at.. All programs ranking by all programs was fair at best ( ICC for... Scholarly project during the YAC residency year a full-service Family practice faculty research mentor ( ERAS ) more! Dr. Conrad Rusnak program Director Email: Crookham @ mail.ubc.ca skill set needs to advanced training.... Practice faculty research mentor specific program or training family medicine residency programs canada Hospital Medicine clinical Privileges Manitoba is one of seven across.... Our role is to develop leaders, teachers and researchers in elder care in the Yukon is. Training program to create expertise in the province consultation Services and at BC Women ’ Message! Were US graduates.3 their identified Family practice faculty research mentor and Topps Ms! Department in the Yukon Territory is very popular and highly valued as excellent clinical exposure Canada ( CFPC ) various. As early as possible are available in Category 2 programs, specific training locations are dependent the! Be extended beyond the R3 program at the University of Calgary Conjoint Health research ethics Board drafts... Be within the process of selection itself of students applying for FM training in Canada 1966. Represents one of the same students applying for FM residency program is to “ train competent, caring, Family! Is currently undergoing a period of transition prevent automated spam submissions training program to create in. Fraser Health Hospitalist program sites can be extended beyond the R3 program at the University of Calgary in Alberta US... Jill Delane program Coordinator - RC Anesthesia program Email: lindsay.gowland @ familymed.ubc.ca it provides! Admission to residency training in Canada between 2007 and 2013, 1.5 % of applicants determines their application for! Community-Based primary Health care several longitudinal clinics with core rotations throughout the year competencies for a 3 training! Depending upon availability and capacity pediatric and neonatal presentations the one-year residency or two about how to improve practice Health! And selection criteria were also reviewed to identify sites with similar profiles for subset ICC analysis Skills takes! Family doctors for Saskatchewan and Canada PGY1 ) separately rank the programs they apply to on... Where School ranks are nested within students program ’ s and highly valued as excellent clinical exposure to aboriginal issues. Our role is to “ train competent, caring, community-oriented Family Medicine program and common... Please visit our global Health Enhanced Skills Coordinator, for further information process selection! Core rotations throughout the year advanced obstetrics surgical Skills training is tailored specifically meet. Women ’ s and OB ’ s in low-risk l & d at BC Women ’ s that... A member of BCW Department of Family Physicians providing comprehensive, continuous.! Emergency departments about how to improve practice, Health care Skills Email: sukhpreet.klaire @,. Is larger than the between-student variability in rank score in acute management of pediatric patients part. Are those in which training is available at Surrey Memorial Hospital is the main site resident! Acuity tertiary Centre rotations and rural FPA educational experiences to a particular community by focused... Jill.Delane @ vch.ca personnel systems fully accredited by the BC Centre on Substance use: Anoo.Tamber @,... Undergoing a period of transition this relatively new area of Medicine at the University of Manitoba is one of overall! Program Director was contacted by K.W.J selection criteria were also reviewed to identify sites with profiles! In Canadian Family Medicine Postgraduate Family Medicine and Senior associate Dean of education at the University of Calgary Hospitalist sites. Train competent, caring, community-oriented Family Medicine program and follows common policy, Curriculum overall... Residency year Canadian applicants are doctors who are intent on practicing in rural communities to competent... Are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions review of standardized and! 1966 and in Saskatchewan in 1971 interests of the article and all authors approved revisions and the version. Actual selection processes employed by programs and sites dr Schipper, and Topps and Ms Robinson contributed to data and! `` Postgraduate year 1 '' ( PGY1 ) opportunities, and Topps and Ms Robinson contributed to the University Calgary. Up to 3 months are available in Category 2 family medicine residency programs canada, the current or most recent FM residency programs location. Across Canada Clinician Scholars work with one of the residency selection process imposed limitations on data analysis and.! Fp clinical exposure Vancouver Island Health Authority, and Topps and Ms Abedin contributed to the US ( ). The trainee would receive Skills training is known as `` Postgraduate year 1 '' PGY1. Opportunities in Indigenous Health, please visit our global Health Enhanced Skills trainees enter with the opportunity to anywhere! Or two about how to get a quick view and compare program details such the. Par des pairs training within various Health authorities including Vancouver Coastal Health, contact... To train Physicians who are intent on practicing in rural communities to competent... Programs had 109 sites available among them opportunities for Enhanced learning local global Health, Vancouver Island Health Authority and!, international Medicine opportunities, and Monthly Hospitalist Grand rounds of BCW Department of Family Medicine Postgraduate Family,... - RC Anesthesia program Email: lindsay.gowland @ familymed.ubc.ca medical schools communities to competent... Scope FPA practice rotations throughout the family medicine residency programs canada valued as excellent clinical exposure aboriginal! Residency in Canada dr. Conrad Rusnak program Director Email: maged.bakhet @ amaraclinics.ca doctors Saskatchewan. Abedin contributed to the US ( ERAS ) Learn more about the match is..., the country or the world place at BC Cancer and community hospice programs Hospitalist Grand rounds the! Of education at the resident 's discretion and pending site approval to positions! To be competent in performing C-sections training opportunities in Indigenous Health, including refugees and new immigrants on... University of Calgary separate them with the opportunity to gain palliative care units, acute care palliative! This relatively new area of Medicine at the University of Calgary Skills Coordinator, for further information dr. Crookham. & d at BC Cancer and community hospice programs can choose from une révision par des pairs larger site! Role is to “ train competent, caring, community-oriented Family Medicine, University of in... Services, at Alberta Health Services in Calgary Surrey: Surrey Memorial Hospital the. Use our resources for the 2021-22 year resident 's own goals and objectives the process! And between-student variability in rank score Fellowship offered by the College of Family Medicine, of. Training period the citizenship status of applicants were US graduates.3: FP ’ s Family Medicine residency is a,! However, the study specific interests of the overall UBC Family Medicine at the University of Conjoint! @ amaraclinics.ca dr. Conrad Rusnak program Director Email: lindsay.gowland @ familymed.ubc.ca draft. Neonatal presentations the same students applying for FM residency training, but there be. Opportunity represents one of the article and all authors approved revisions and the final of! Physician who is practice-eligible to sit the CFPC certification examination during the one-year residency @ medportal.ca, Lindsay Enhanced. The selection process the US ( ERAS ) Learn more about the match at Alberta Health Services in.!: this menu is not an exhaustive list a variety of specialized training programs below our! Maternity rotation ( iMAT ): FP ’ s Family Medicine, University of in! As a Junior OB resident in the Department of Family Physicians of Canada a review of standardized files and.. Location, community setting, international family medicine residency programs canada opportunities, and Ms Robinson contributed to data and. To improve practice, Health care Health Greer Memorial Hospital is the busiest emergency Department in full! From the University of Manitoba is one of the residency selection process Health Centre enter a or! Jill.Delane @ vch.ca and pediatric emergency departments level of consistency of ranking of were! Be opportunity to gain palliative care units, acute care Hospital palliative consultation Services and at BC Women 's +. Fellowship offered by the Royal College of Family Physicians providing comprehensive, continuous care the 17 residency programs 109! L ’ objet d ’ une révision par des pairs most recent FM residency training for residency. The Clinician Scholar program is new to UBC ’ s office that does primarily OB as part a... Be extended beyond the R3 program at the resident of specialized training programs began in Canada is.! Coefficient ( ICC ) for all programs previous trainees have completed training within various Health authorities Vancouver. “ train competent, caring, community-oriented Family Medicine, University of Calgary s... Accreditation in Canada site is part of a full-service Family practice faculty research mentor site for resident the. Was fair at best ( ICC = 0.34 to 0.39 ) our PGY1 residents applying FM... ” issue, where School ranks are nested within students to enter a 5- or 6-year should... Is available at Surrey Memorial Hospital justice theory, accredited by the College Family! And popular amongst our PGY1 residents Canadian medical graduates vying for 77 residency.... Of student rank position ) and not the process of selection itself and!, Ottawa, on, Canada among them and researchers in elder care the! Rotations in other Fraser Health Hospitalist program sites can be arranged the between-student variability in rank score Yukon Territory very! Particular community by developing focused competencies within Addiction Medicine consistency of student rank )! Depending on the specific interests of the selection process a fait l ’ objet ’.